What is the Best Plant-Based Peanut Butter? Top Vegan Peanut Butter Brands in 2019

Many people around the world love peanut butter, whether they’re vegan or not, and it’s a staple in thousands of diets–particularly in America. However, if you adhere to a vegan lifestyle, you need to begin to pay more attention to what’s in the food products you invest in, and peanut butter is no different. While peanut butter naturally tends to be vegan (the main ingredient is peanuts, and despite the name, there’s no butter) it can be surprising to see how many weird ingredients, chemicals, or fillers popular brands stuff into their ingredient lists. 

Often, weird ingredients or ones you can’t pronounce turn out to be animal derived. To make sure you can continue eating your beloved peanut butter, it’s a good idea to invest in better brands that have simpler ingredient lists yet are tasty and healthy. Rather than adding unnecessary stabilizers, sugars, or oils, you can try sticking to a product that’s simple and has three or four ingredients at the most. Remember: the closer you can stick to just peanuts, the better. 

Top 5 Vegan Peanut Butter Brands

Peanut Butter & Co. Top Sellers Variety Pack **TOP PICK**5 out of 5 stars
NAKED Nutrition Premium Powdered Peanut Butter4.8 out of 5 stars
Spread The Love Naked Organic Peanut Butter 4.7 out of 5 stars
FATSO High Performance Natural Peanut Butter4.6 out of 5 stars
Teddie All Natural Peanut Butter 4.5 out of 5 stars

Luckily, there are many peanut brands out there that understand this, and they attempt to provide their customers with the healthiest, simplest peanut butter possible. With a little research, it’s not too difficult to find peanut butter that’s completely vegan friendly. Keep an eye out for ingredients like honey, which is often used as a sweetener, and other things that seem harmless but are indeed animal derived. If you’re vegan, you can feel rest assured; peanut butter is one of those few products that’s generally a safe food to invest in. Whether you’re looking for something to add to your bananas, sandwiches, or smoothies, the top seven vegan peanut butters below are great options to check out so you can get started. 

The Best Vegan Peanut Butter List


Peanut Butter & Co. Top Sellers Variety Pack 

Peanut Butter & Co. is a very well known brand, and with this purchase, you get an excellent variety pack of all of the company’s top sellers. You’ll get one 16oz jar each of Peanut Butter & Co.’s Dark Chocolately Dreams, White Chocolately Wonderful, Crunch Time, and Smooth Operator. They’re perfect anytime as a snack or to supplement a meal, and each flavor is Non-GMO project verified, vegan, and gluten free. Made with honest, simple ingredients, this peanut butter supports the production of certified sustainable palm oil. You’ll get zero grams of trans fat and up to seven grams of protein per serving, all without any high fructose corn syrup, hydrogenated oil, or cholesterol. The variety pack is an excellent way for you to try all the flavors and discover your favorite. The peanut butter is delicious with oatmeal, fruit, or sandwiches. It can also be included in your favorite recipes, or enjoyed by the spoonful right out of the jar. With Peanut Butter & Co., you can indulge in a product that does good, makes you feel good, and tastes good. Its products are made from peanuts that are only grown in the USA.

thumbs-up-icon

Pros

  • Up to 7 grams of protein per serving 
  • Variety pack of flavors allows you to discover your favorite 
  • Non-GMO project verified and free of hydrogenated oil or high fructose corn syrup

thumbs-down-icon

Cons

  • Ingredients include added oil and added sugar 
  • Has an odd, greasy aftertaste 


NAKED Nutrition Premium Powdered Peanut Butter

This premium peanut butter from NAKED nutrition comes in a unique form: powder. A purchase will give you two pounds of the stuff, which features roasted peanuts that are grown on US farms. Available in bulk, this vegan peanut butter has absolutely no sugar, soy, dairy, salt, preservatives, or additives and contains just one, simple ingredient: 100% non-GMO USA roasted peanuts. This ingredient is sourced exclusively from local farms, and it’s packaged and processed here in the USA as well. The powder has been tested for the presence or trace of any heavy metals, and it has been found to be safe by third parties that have independently tested the powder. You’ll get maximum nutrition from this vegan superfood, as it offers six grams of protein, four grams of carbs, almost one gram of BCAAs, and just 50 calories per serving–making it perfect for all types of diets, especially ones that focus on low calories and a low amount of carbs. The BCAAs are an added bonus, as they’re the building blocks for your muscles and are essential for an active lifestyle. If you’re looking for vegan peanut butter, NAKED nutrition’s powdered product is a great option and can be incorporated into all kinds of recipes, or eaten all by itself.

thumbs-up-icon

Pros

  • One ingredient: 100% non-GMO roasted peanuts 
  • Independently tested by third parties for heavy metals 
  • Offers protein yet a low amount of calories, fats, and carbs 

thumbs-down-icon

Cons

  • Smell of the powder may be odd or off 
  • Many users thought that the product lacks flavor and is very bland


Spread The Love Naked Organic Peanut Butter 

Spread The Love’s organic peanut butter is completely organic, vegan, gluten free, and all natural. You’ll get a 16 ounce jar of dry-roasted, creamy peanut butter that has absolutely no added salt or sugar, and it features just one simple ingredient: organic dry-roasted peanuts. It’s made with attention and care here in the USA in California, and it’s created in small batches from an all-natural company that’s family owned and operated. A small batch production lends to higher quality, nutrition, and flavor, and helps to reduce unnecessary food processing. Spread The Love aims to solve all of your needs for healthy food products that contain the most minimal ingredients possible, and peanut butter is a great product that’s easily simple and natural. This peanut butter in particular is also certified to be kosher, doesn’t contain any palm oil or dairy, is non-GMO, and there are absolutely no preservatives, fillers, or chemicals used. The special blend of peanuts is naturally oily and sweet, which is why palm oil did not need to be included, and it’s great just the way it is. If you want high quality, no-junk, fresh peanut butter that’s creamy and all natural, this is the perfect product for you. On top of all of this, Spread The Love is also Clean AF certified, meaning that you can trust on it being healthy and clean.

thumbs-up-icon

Pros

  • Certified Kosher and Clean AF 
  • One ingredient: dry roasted peanuts that are naturally sweet and oily 
  • Minimal processing and made in small batches 

thumbs-down-icon

Cons

  • Many users felt that the texture is too thin and liquidy 
  • Due to the peanuts being oily, it’s difficult to mix the product and achieve a classic peanut butter consistency 


FATSO High Performance Natural Peanut Butter

FATSO’s natural peanut butter helps you achieve the highest strength, endurance, and performance you possibly can. This product is vegan and contains plant-based superfats, such as coconut oil, flax, sweet tapioca, avocado oil, and MCT oil, which provide power for all your daily activities. It’s an excellent product to invest in if you’re on the Keto diet or any other type of diet where you need to consume a high amount of fats and protein, and many athletes, bodybuilders, and weight lifters choose this to support their workouts. FATSO’s peanut butter is a great way to upgrade your classic peanut butter snacks or dishes, and it’s a much healthier alternative to many other brands out there. Loaded with healthy fats, protein, and fiber, you’ll still get that classic peanut butter taste you love, despite the addition of coconut, flax, and chia seeds. It also contains all natural ingredients, and a simple ingredient list includes: MCT oil, ground flax seeds, chia seeds, avocado oil, tapioca fiber, organic coconut oil, and peanuts–no gluten, dairy, sugars, preservatives, or fillers added. FATSO is also non-GMO certified and completely vegan–as well as delicious. You’ll get a nutritional boost to your overall health as you get a dose of vitamins, antioxidants, calcium, iron, fiber, minerals, and fatty acids to help stabilize your metabolism, power your performance, lower cholesterol, promote the burning of fat, and keep you feeling full for a long time. Bursting with natural flavor and enhanced with tapioca fiber so it’s easy to digest and promotes healthy bacteria, this peanut butter is the perfect snack to take on the go for all your daily activities.

thumbs-up-icon

Pros

  • Simple ingredient list of all natural superfats and peanuts 
  • Offers fatty acids, vitamins, minerals, antioxidants, and fiber 
  • Enhances your whole health as it helps to burn fat and keep you feeling full 

thumbs-down-icon

Cons

  • This product tends to be very runny
  • Expensive investment


Teddie All Natural Peanut Butter 

Teddie’s peanut butter is super smooth, all natural, and vegan. You’ll get three 26 ounce jars with a purchase, all of which are vegan friendly, gluten free, and non-GMO. This is true, natural peanut butter–not a simple peanut butter “spread”. It aims to support your whole health and provide a tasty, healthy, clean snack. With no added sugars or preservatives, you can feel good eating this peanut butter, as it’s also made using only peanuts grown in the USA and is proudly entirely made in the USA by a company that has been family owned and operated for almost a hundred years. You’ll discover that this is among the most nutritious and delicious peanut butters currently available, and it’s made with just peanuts. Additionally, you can buy it in either an unsalted or salted variety, which is great news for people trying to cut down on their sodium or who need to avoid salt for health reasons. It’s also available in two different sizes, which makes it perfect for testing out. With no additives, oils, or sweeteners, you’ll get just peanuts and salt that burst with flavor. Whether you like adding your peanut butter to a smoothie, a sandwich, or you enjoy just eating it straight from the jar, this product is healthy and delicious.

thumbs-up-icon

Pros

  • Available in either salted or unsalted 
  • Contains only high quality grades of nuts 
  • Just two ingredients 

thumbs-down-icon

Cons

  • Has an odd chalky texture and taste 
  • Salt variety has a very high level of sodium content 


Fix and Fogg Gourmet Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter 

This peanut butter from Fix and Fogg features a unique, tasty pairing that many people love: peanut butter with gourmet dark chocolate. It’s handmade in New Zealand and contains 62% dark chocolate for a unique, superior taste that makes it stand out among the market. Fix and Fogg also works hard to produce foods that are good for you; this peanut butter is vegan, non-GMO, keto friendly, healthy, free of any palm oil, and naturally low in sugar. The company uses only the best, most high quality ingredients, and it handmakes all of its products through a small, award-winning team located in Wellington. It aims to be completely hands-on throughout the entire process, to ensure you get great, artisan peanut butter. 62% dark chocolate is used, as well as a tiny amount of New Zealand sea salt, and golden roasted hi-oleic peanuts that provide the perfect crunch. You’ll taste the difference, and can keep this peanut butter to yourself to add to meals and snacks, or wrap it up for a gourmet gift you’ll be proud to give to your friends. Try this on toast, pancakes, ice cream or cereal–or treat yourself by spooning it right out of the jar for a treat or dessert. If you love delicious and pure peanut butter, you’re in the right place–and on top of it all, Fix & Fogg offers a money back guarantee and you’ll get your refund with no questions asked, risk free.

thumbs-up-icon

Pros

  • Three ingredients: peanuts, dark chocolate, and sea salt 
  • Handmade by a small, award-winning team 
  • Golden roasted hi-oleic peanuts provide the perfect crunch 

thumbs-down-icon

Cons

  • Some users felt that there is no chocolate flavor, and the dry roasted peanut flavor is overpowering 
  • Tends to stick to the roof of the mouth


NuttZo Organic Smooth Peanut Pro Nut and Seed Butter 

NuttZo’s smooth and organic peanut butter features a medley of both nuts and seeds: you’ll find seven organic ingredients such as pumpkin seeds, chia seeds, hazelnuts, flax seeds, brazil nuts, almonds, and cashews. Topped with a pinch of Celtic sea salt, you can get the peanut butter in either a smooth or crunchy flavor, and in 12 ounce jars or single serving packets that are easy to take on the go. NuttZo provides you with excellent, superfood nutrition that supports your whole health due to the variety of seeds and nuts in every spoonful. Each jar that is sold also supports Project Left Behind, an organization that helps neglected children. The company is also USDA certified organic, paleo, kosher, gluten free, non-GMO, and vegan. Not only is their peanut butter delicious, it’s also nutritious, as it’s nutrient dense, low in sugar, and every serving provides you with 520mg of omega-3 fatty acids and six grams of protein. All ingredients are non-GMO, vegan, and kosher. Overall, you can feel good about snacking on this peanut butter and taking it on the go, as it provides a nutritional boost you won’t find in many other products. It’s a healthy, versatile treat and you can add it to smoothies, pancakes, fruits, veggies, crackers, desserts, or just scoop it by the spoonful to treat yourself. NuttZo is the original multi-nut and seed butter and offers more than just seeds and nuts for its consumers and people around the world.

thumbs-up-icon

Pros

  • Six grams of protein and 520mg of omega-3s per serving 
  • Contains a medley of nuts and seeds; original multi-nut and seed butter 
  • Available in jars or in to-go single serving packs, and original or crunchy variety to satisfy anyone’s preferences 

thumbs-down-icon

Cons

  • Much more oily than traditional peanut butter 
  • Expensive investment 


Conclusion & What is the Best Vegan Peanut Butter Brand

Peanut butter definitely has a safe place in your plant based, whole foods diet. Typically, it’s vegan friendly anyways, but to make sure you’re completely adhering to your vegan lifestyle, it’s a good choice to check out the ingredient list of your favorite peanut butters and keep an eye out for sneaky ingredients like honey. Remember: the closer you are to just peanuts, the better. Shortened ingredient lists, as well as brands that have been certified to be vegan and organic, are your best bet. No matter what, peanuts should be the first ingredient listed. After that, a little natural sweetener, salt, or flavoring like dark chocolate are all safe for vegans. Another place to check, beyond the ingredient list, is the nutrition panel; if the carb or fat count seems oddly high, chances are that the peanut butter you’re holding is full of added sugars or oils, and you’ll want to cut it out to keep up with a healthy diet. 

As a vegan, it’s important to remember that healthy diets are all about balance. As with anything, you should treat yourself sometimes, and for many vegans, a spoonful of peanut butter straight from the jar or a scoop drizzled with vegan ice cream, oatmeal, pancakes, or chocolate can be the healthy vegan treat you deserve. Check out our favorite, Peanut Butter & Co. (CHECK BEST PRICE HERE).

Best Vegan Peanut Butter in 2019
4.9 (98.18%) 44 vote[s]